Guides
Tequila vs. Mezcal: What Actually Changes in the Glass
July 28, 2026 · 6 min read
All tequila is mezcal by definition — mezcal simply means a spirit distilled from agave. What separates them on the shelf is which agave is allowed, where it can be made, and how the plants are cooked before fermentation.
The rules behind the labels
Tequila must be made from blue Weber agave and produced in Jalisco or a handful of approved municipalities in four neighboring states. Mezcal can be made from dozens of agave species — espadín is the workhorse, with tobalá, tepeztate and others appearing in smaller batches — and is produced across nine Mexican states, with Oaxaca the best known.
Look for '100% agave' on a tequila label. Anything without it is a mixto, legally allowed up to 49% other sugars, and it is usually the reason someone tells you they cannot drink tequila.
Why mezcal tastes smoky and tequila does not
It comes down to cooking. Tequila producers steam agave in ovens or autoclaves. Traditional mezcal producers roast the agave hearts in earthen pits lined with hot rock and wood, then cover them for days. That pit contact is where the smoke lives — it is a process, not a flavoring.
Smoke also varies enormously. A well-made espadín can read as gentle campfire and green pepper, not the ashtray people brace for.
Reading the age statements
Blanco or joven is unaged and the truest picture of the distillery. Reposado rests two to twelve months in oak and gains vanilla and baking spice. Añejo sits one to three years and drinks closer to a whiskey. Extra añejo runs past three years and is a sipping purchase.
Most mezcal is sold unaged on purpose, because oak covers the agave and terroir that people buy mezcal for in the first place.
How to choose tonight
Mixing a margarita, paloma or ranch water: blanco tequila. Sipping neat after dinner: reposado or añejo tequila, or an espadín mezcal if you want something more savory. Want one bottle that does both: a good reposado is the safest single purchase in the category.
If you are new to mezcal, taste it neat at room temperature in a small pour before you decide. Ice mutes it, and a first impression through a cocktail tells you very little.
- Margaritas and palomas — blanco tequila
- After-dinner sipping — reposado, añejo, or espadín mezcal
- One bottle for everything — reposado tequila
- Smoky cocktails — swap a half ounce of mezcal into a tequila drink
Get the bottles delivered
Same-day delivery and curbside pickup from all three stores.
Shop the ingredients
Find the bottles in this post on our shelves.